Hawking vs Alien

Stephen Hawking is in the news for reports on his comments on the inadvisability of communicating with aliens. We’ll have to wait for the full Discovery Channel series to see what he really said, and keep in mind it’s a made-for-TV statement. But it does give me an early morning hook to bang out a post instead of prepping for class.

There’s two reasons why the “hide and watch or they’ll loot us” approach is wrong. First off. The hide and watch part won’t work. It’s not the “Hello World” signals that SETItionists and other astronomers send out that will attract attention, it’s our normal human activity. First, of course, are our radio and TV transmissions. While all information in the signals will have degraded before it gets beyond much beyond the nearest stars, the carrier wave will still be there. Second is our military/aviation activities. We transmit lots of high power radar signals. We used to transmit even more, with our BMEWS and the Soviet Hen House radars. Those signals will be detectable long after “Lucy” has faded. Finally, there’s the big blue ball itself. We are getting to the point that we will soon be able to detect earth-like planets at great distances and, under special circumstances, detect signs of life, like liquid water and an oxygen atmosphere. So don’t worry about talking to the aliens, they’ll know we’re here long before we can think of what to say.

The second reason involves the looting and pillaging part of Hawking’s concerns. I am not going to talk about the morals of aliens. I suspect they will be incomprehensible to us (you know, alien). What I would argue is the old argument for having us Earthlingas establishing a space-based civilization — it’s raining soup out there and all we need is a bowl. There’s nothing in the way of resources at the bottom of the Earth’s gravity well that a space-faring people couldn’t get far more easily elsewhere. Metals? Melt down an asteroid. Petrochemicals? Go mine Titan. I seriously doubt that any race capable of interstellar viking isn’t also capable of building any long-chain organic molecule they want, using water from the outer solar system, and solar power from the inner…erm…solar…system.

That leaves lebensraum, and there you have me. A oxy-water world may be rare, and might be the target of colonization. But if you have built your civilization around living in an FTL habitat, or a generation ship for that matter, your mindset is to get the stuff you need from the Oort or the Main Belt, and leave the gravity wells alone.

The final reason I am not worried about this is my take on the Fermi Question. From everything I can see, in our Galaxy, right now, n = 1 and it’s us. I’ll have more to say about that in future. Right now I have to go prep.

Tags: , , ,

3 Responses to “Hawking vs Alien”

  1. Steve Beckow Says:

    Actually many galactics are visiting Earth at this time. You only need to google “UFOs” on Youtube to see that.

    And the galactics are communicating to us profusely about why they are here. Google “Mike Quinsey” and “SaLuSa of Sirius” for one of the best channels of communication.

    Benign galactics have assisted us to curtail the secret government, responsible for HAARP-induced earthquakes and volcanoes, laboratory-manufactured pandemics (AIDS, SARS, H1N1, for instance), financial undermining of national economies, the paeonization of labor, intended nuclear warfare, and many other circumstances that we could not have managed ourselves. We owe these benign galactics a great deal.

    The Americans ridicule the existence of “aliens” because that allows them to hold onto secret technologies that they have obtained from back-engineering alien technology from spacecraft crashes like Roswell. From Roswell, they salvaged the silicon chip, kevlar, teflon, fibre optic technology, and other “inventions.”

    You’ll be surprised to know that the Americans run a secret space agency and already have spacecraft (the TR3-B Aurora is one example) and bases on the Moon and Mars. NASA is just for show.

    The benign galactics are here to help us end the cycle in 2012 and move to a new level. While there were dark galactics here, principally the Anunnaki and Zeta Reticulans (or “little Greys”), most of these have now left.

    The benign galactics who remain are predominantly human in form, the human body being a common feature among aliens.

    Drop by “The 2012 Scenario” at http://sbeckow.wordpress.com or visit “First Contact” at http://www.angelfire.com/space2/light11/fc/fc-index1.html, if you wish to pursue the topic.

    There is no need not to know the whole story.


    Steve Beckow

  2. Kurt Says:

    It’s the microscopic space bugs that give me the willies. They don’t need a reason to transverse space and infect us. It’s just what they do. And they’re so little, we’ll never see them coming.

    On the positive side, they’ll act as natural universal translators. Suddenly, we’ll be able to hear and talk to the birds and bees. All day long. All night long. We’ll hear the bedbugs. We’ll go nuts and the microbes will mop up and move on.

    Stephen Hawking don’t know the one over pi of it.

  3. Response to “Hawking vs. Alien” « The 2012 Scenario Says:

    […] generated)Steven Greer’s Response to Stephen Hawking on “Bad Aliens”Hawking vs AlienHawking: Aliens’ may pose risks to Earth?Elvis Costello: watching the […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: